- “News briefs” will appear on the Google TV For You page
- Will recommend related videos of “top news stories”
- Only in the US, and only being tested with some users
Google is experimenting with AI-powered news summaries and recommendations that you’ll be able to see on your Google TV. This seems like a very bad idea.
The feature, called News Briefs, was spotted by Android Authority on the Google support pages. It will use “Gemini models and human evaluation” to provide narrated overviews of top news stories and “related YouTube videos from trusted news sources.”
So far it’s only being tested with selected users, and it’s only being tested in the US. And I hope that at the end of the test, they kill it with fire.
The problem with AI news is simple
The thing about AI is that, for want of a better description, it’s a massive miscommunication machine. To take a pretty innocuous example, Apple’s AI headlines have been a disaster, and its AI summaries on my iPhone are often hilariously wrong.
Again and again we see very clear evidence that AI can’t be trusted currently. Sometimes it’s funny – as the Associated Press found in the summer of 2024, Gemini will happily tell you that astronauts have played with cats on the moon – but sometimes it’s much more serious; the same report notes that Google’s AI shared the conspiracy theory that Barack Obama is muslim.
The problem with AI is that what we’re told is AI… isn’t. It’s like a very high-powered autocorrect, a prediction machine, and when its data is bad – and it often is – then it produces bad information with great confidence. And online there’s an entire ecosystem based on making bad information and feeding it into social media such as YouTube.
Given YouTube’s track record in recommendations – NBC News is one of many organizations that demonstrated a political and religious bias in the content being recommended to people, for example – having AI-powered news recommendations pushed to us even when we haven’t asked to see new sounds terrifying.
And on top of that, I get plenty of nightmarish news delivered to me all day, every day on my phone – perhaps if I’ve turned on my TV it’s to escape, or be distracted, or entertained. Some people love to watch rolling news (or news-style) networks all day, but some of us use our TV to focus elsewhere.
There’s enough bad news in the world right now. I really hope Google TV isn’t going to add more of it.